K/A Summer Dress and jacket

I'm wearing a dress-over-jeans today, and remembered that I've been debating for a couple of years now on whether to alter the dress into a top.

First - it's kind of that awkward just-above-the-knee length. It's modest enough, but I'm not sure I like the length without something under it.

Second - it doesn't have pockets, so when worn over jeans (like here), it makes the jeans pockets hard to access without offering any alternative.

Otherwise, it's a nice summer weight performance fabric, and is comfortable to wear, and I still like the pattern.  It's a bit bunchy to tuck in (see pic #3).  Should I give it the chop?  (Or perhaps I should add pockets instead?)

Also auditioning a white summer jacket.  Does it work?

This post is also published in the youlookfab forum. You can read and reply to it in either place. All replies will appear in both places.


  • Sloper replied 6 days ago

    I really like the whole look and proportions of #4, so maybe chop the dress.  The white jacket is a good topper!

  • Murph11 replied 6 days ago

    Oh, I like it as a top!

  • Angie replied 6 days ago

    Another vote to hack to a top. Lovely pattern. #4 is FABULOUS! 

  • Sloper replied 6 days ago

    Also adding - I think what I'm also really liking is the collared jacket - the collar is flattering.

  • shevia replied 6 days ago

    I say chop.

  • rachylou replied 6 days ago

    I will go with the crowd and say chop - it’s a cute top! Looks great with the white jacket.

  • Karie replied 6 days ago

    Turn it into a top! It looks nice as a dress, but I like it best as a top.

  • notsaf replied 6 days ago

    Agreed: great jacket and clever save!

  • fin42 replied 6 days ago

    I prefer it as a top but maybe before you go for the chop a belt on around it to give it some more shape?

  • Brooklyn replied 6 days ago

    Chop. Chop!

    What a pretty pattern.

    Another option, as it looks like it’s loose enough, is to chop it horizontally just below the armholes and turn it into a midi skirt with an elastic waist. Just depends what you would find more useful.

  • Star replied 6 days ago

    I like it as is with the jeans.

  • unfrumped replied 6 days ago

    I love the tucked - in outfit. Those are great proportions on you and everything fits in a very nice easy way. . The neckline is great, and the black& white in the print are fab with the jacket and jeans and black accessories. As a top, that is an outfit I’d wear over and over and feel good in- it tucks really well.
    Chop- chop!

  • RobinF replied 6 days ago

    I vote chop. I love it as a dress but if you aren't wearing it that way then go for the chop.

  • Sheila replied 5 days ago

    I like it better as a top. I think you will get more use of it that way.

  • Helena replied 5 days ago

    Yes to a hack, and YLF!

  • DonnaF replied 4 days ago

    Yes, chop! Looking at the pattern, would you do it more tunic length and enable in-seam pockets? Or would you chop to the next pattern up to make it more conventional top length? 

  • Jonesy replied 3 days ago

    Is it unanimous? I say chop as well!

You need to be logged in to comment